Robin Marx's Writing Repository

This review originally appeared on Goodreads on June 6, 2012.

Secret Operative K-13

By Joel Townsley Rogers – Black Dog Books – April 17, 2012

Review by Robin Marx

Set during World War I, this pulp tale (serialized in Everybody's Magazine from late 1928 to early 1929) focuses on a British spy far behind German enemy lines and the Sopwith Camel pilot (Richard “Big Dick” Fahrnestock) sent on a suicide mission to rendezvous with the enigmatic operative.

From the earliest pages, this book has a considerable amount of cheese, with General von Schmee speaking like Colonel Klink. Monocles abound. Keeping things fair, the British and American characters are also heavily stereotyped. The British squadron commander is straight out of Blackadder Goes Forth (“Eh, what?”) and Big Dick Farhnestock is the epitome of the big, dumb-as-a-brick, tough-as-nails American hero. The espionage plot is functional but not spectacular, with enough twists (and a couple obvious ones) to provide a few surprises over the course of the book.

One of the exciting things about pulp fiction is that it often surprises you; many pulp stories are much better than you'd expect them to be. They were churned out at a brisk pace by writers who were generally more interested in paying that month's bills than creating anything of any lasting artistic value. Even so, a fraction of these stories stand the test of time, presenting a surprisingly original character or presenting a beautifully rendered action sequence. Unfortunately, this is not quite up to that level. The first 75% of it is enjoyable dumb fun, but the climax is so gripping that the story as a whole actually suffers. The last quarter of the book reveals Joel Townsley Rogers as a fairly talented writer, which makes me wonder why there was so much cheesiness in the earlier chapters. Laziness? Tight deadlines?

Released for the first time in book form by Black Dog Books, I'd only recommend this to existing pulp fans. It's a fun story, but too uneven.

★★★☆☆

#CapsuleReviewArchive #BookReview #PulpFiction #SecretOperativeK13 #JoelTownsleyRogers